Appraisal Report

Overpriced

Item Identity

Vintage Natural Jade Bracelet & Earrings Set (Sterling Silver)

Fair Market Value Estimate

$120 - $180

Original Retail Price

$350 - $450

Confidence

High

Analysis

The listing describes a vintage sterling silver (925) set with 'natural untreated jadeite.' While the craftsmanship matches mid-century Chinese export jewelry, the price is high for uncertified jade on the secondary market. Similar vintage silver and jade link bracelets typically sell for $80-$120 on eBay or Etsy, with earrings adding another $30-$50 value. The fact that the post has been up for 6 months confirms the market has rejected the $250 price point. Without a gemologist certificate proving these are Grade A Jadeite, they should be priced closer to standard decorative stone jewelry.

Market References & Alternatives

[Debug] Toggle Screenshot
Captured Screenshot
[Debug] Toggle AI Response
{
  "identity": "Vintage Natural Jade Bracelet & Earrings Set (Sterling Silver)",
  "fmv_estimate": "$120 - $180",
  "original_price": "$350 - $450",
  "verdict": "Overpriced",
  "analysis": "The listing describes a vintage sterling silver (925) set with 'natural untreated jadeite.' While the craftsmanship matches mid-century Chinese export jewelry, the price is high for uncertified jade on the secondary market. Similar vintage silver and jade link bracelets typically sell for $80-$120 on eBay or Etsy, with earrings adding another $30-$50 value. The fact that the post has been up for 6 months confirms the market has rejected the $250 price point. Without a gemologist certificate proving these are Grade A Jadeite, they should be priced closer to standard decorative stone jewelry.",
  "alternatives": [
    {
      "name": "Vintage Sterling Silver Jade Link Bracelet (Etsy/eBay)",
      "price": "$85 - $125",
      "url": "https://www.etsy.com/market/vintage_jade_silver_bracelet"
    },
    {
      "name": "Ross-Simons Jade Bracelet in Sterling Silver (New)",
      "price": "$131",
      "url": "https://www.ross-simons.com/jewelry/bracelets/jade"
    }
  ]
}